S38 · 38 proposed systems11 preliminary illustrative gross scenarios27 uncosted systemsVerified whole-program net savings: not available
S38, debt & governance framework · October 2026 · evidence before advocacy

The Economic Case.

Australia runs many of the same administrative systems several times over. S38 argues that national standards with regional delivery could free capacity for frontline services. It does not claim that this is proven, and it does not report a net saving that no one has verified.

proposed systems
38
preliminary illustrative gross scenarios
11
uncosted
27
verified net impact not available
N/A

The argument

Duplicated procurement, ICT, registration, back-office and regulatory systems across nine governments carry real cost. A single national framework could reduce that duplication over time.

The limit

Only 11 of 38 systems carry an inherited illustrative gross figure. Transition, dual-running, workforce, legal and new operating costs are not yet costed, so the net effect is unknown.

The commitment

Before any benefit is booked or reinvested, it must be independently costed, audited and reported to Parliament, with service outcomes published alongside it.

The S38 scenario

$6.2625bn a year, gross, at maturity — if the assumptions hold.

Ten per cent of expenditure in 11 systems is assumed addressable, and 15% of that is assumed saved. On the staged ramp the illustrative gross totals are $38.514375bn over 10 years, $101.139375bn over 20 years, $163.764375bn over 30 years. These are gross scenario values before any costs, not a promised fiscal dividend.

Gross scenario, not a net or guaranteed benefit. Figures are inherited modelling assumptions in constant dollars. Transition costs, new operating responsibilities, National Service costs, inflation and discounting are excluded. No government-wide net saving is established.

Preliminary illustrative gross scenario, 11 systems, annual, constant dollars — not net, not verified
$0.0bn$3.5bn$7.0bnYear 1: annual $0.000bn, cumulative $0.000bnY1Year 2: annual $0.626bn, cumulative $0.626bnYear 3: annual $1.566bn, cumulative $2.192bnYear 4: annual $2.818bn, cumulative $5.010bnYear 5: annual $4.071bn, cumulative $9.081bnY5Year 6: annual $5.010bn, cumulative $14.091bnYear 7: annual $5.636bn, cumulative $19.727bnYear 8: annual $6.263bn, cumulative $25.989bnYear 9: annual $6.263bn, cumulative $32.252bnYear 10: annual $6.263bn, cumulative $38.514bnY10Year 11: annual $6.263bn, cumulative $44.777bnYear 12: annual $6.263bn, cumulative $51.039bnYear 13: annual $6.263bn, cumulative $57.302bnYear 14: annual $6.263bn, cumulative $63.564bnYear 15: annual $6.263bn, cumulative $69.827bnY15Year 16: annual $6.263bn, cumulative $76.089bnYear 17: annual $6.263bn, cumulative $82.352bnYear 18: annual $6.263bn, cumulative $88.614bnYear 19: annual $6.263bn, cumulative $94.877bnYear 20: annual $6.263bn, cumulative $101.139bnY20Year 21: annual $6.263bn, cumulative $107.402bnYear 22: annual $6.263bn, cumulative $113.664bnYear 23: annual $6.263bn, cumulative $119.927bnYear 24: annual $6.263bn, cumulative $126.189bnYear 25: annual $6.263bn, cumulative $132.452bnY25Year 26: annual $6.263bn, cumulative $138.714bnYear 27: annual $6.263bn, cumulative $144.977bnYear 28: annual $6.263bn, cumulative $151.239bnYear 29: annual $6.263bn, cumulative $157.502bnYear 30: annual $6.263bn, cumulative $163.764bnY30
Show values as a table
YearAnnual grossCumulative gross
1$0.000bn$0.000bn
2$0.626bn$0.626bn
3$1.566bn$2.192bn
4$2.818bn$5.010bn
5$4.071bn$9.081bn
6$5.010bn$14.091bn
7$5.636bn$19.727bn
8$6.263bn$25.989bn
9$6.263bn$32.252bn
10$6.263bn$38.514bn
11$6.263bn$44.777bn
12$6.263bn$51.039bn
13$6.263bn$57.302bn
14$6.263bn$63.564bn
15$6.263bn$69.827bn
16$6.263bn$76.089bn
17$6.263bn$82.352bn
18$6.263bn$88.614bn
19$6.263bn$94.877bn
20$6.263bn$101.139bn
21$6.263bn$107.402bn
22$6.263bn$113.664bn
23$6.263bn$119.927bn
24$6.263bn$126.189bn
25$6.263bn$132.452bn
26$6.263bn$138.714bn
27$6.263bn$144.977bn
28$6.263bn$151.239bn
29$6.263bn$157.502bn
30$6.263bn$163.764bn

Illustrative gross by system, mature annual

Illustrative gross
Modelled potential before costs; not realised or independently audited savings.
Uncosted
No defensible savings amount is available.
Purchaser saving
A reduction in customer bills that may be offset elsewhere; not automatically a net national gain.
Program cost
New expenditure that must be reported separately from efficiency claims.
Verified net — not available
Independently audited realised cash savings less all incremental recurring and transition costs. No verified whole-program net amount exists.

Limitations

  • Only 11 systems have inherited illustrative gross-savings amounts; the other 27 have no validated savings estimate.
  • The scenario assumes 10% of expenditure is addressable and 15% of that amount is saved: a mature gross saving of 1.5% of the assumed baseline.
  • Amounts are constant-dollar scenario values. Inflation, discounting and financing effects are excluded.
  • Some expenditure categories may overlap. Baselines and intergovernmental transfers must be reconciled before aggregation.
  • Full transition costs, new operating responsibilities and National Service costs are not included in the gross-savings total.

Excluded from the total

  • State institutional closure and constitutional/legal work
  • Workforce transfer, redeployment, pensions and industrial obligations
  • Property, debt, contracts and stranded liabilities
  • Cybersecurity, IT replacement, data migration and dual-running
  • Litigation, regional service expansion and new national authorities
  • National Service establishment, recurring costs and economic opportunity costs
Published evidence package

Audit the official baselines in evidence package vOA-ECON-1.0.0.

The machine-readable CSV links page totals to row IDs and records the source URL, release date, reference period, accounting basis, transformation, limitation and reviewer status for every record.

Illustrative inputs cannot be promoted to an official baseline without a named independent reviewer and review date.

This v1 package records official baselines and the earlier illustrative inputs (row IDs such as economic-case:service-base). Those illustrative inputs are superseded by the S38 scenario and are kept for transparency only.
Model v1.1 · baseline 30 June 2025

The scale is in the operating system, not the politicians.

The ABS reports approximately 2.597m public-sector employee jobs in June 2025 and $249.5b in cash wages and salaries for 2024–25. Around 2.211m employee jobs and $208.7b sit at state and local level.

These figures are a scale baseline for verification, not a claim that all jobs or wages are duplicated, removable or available as savings. The independent evidence phase must reconcile definitions, contractors, entities, occupations, regions and frontline versus administrative roles before any percentage is applied.

2.597m

public-sector employee jobs

$249.5b

public-sector wages

2.211m

state + local employee jobs

$208.7b

state + local wages

Potentially addressable

  • Duplicated executive and corporate services
  • Parallel ICT, payroll, HR, legal and procurement platforms
  • Repeated regulatory, licensing and reporting infrastructure
  • Intergovernmental coordination, grants administration and compliance translation

Not a presumed saving

  • Doctors, nurses, teachers, carers, police, paramedics and other frontline roles
  • Regional access, safety standards and culturally specific delivery
  • Existing legal obligations, pensions, contracts and transition costs
  • Any workforce reduction without a published service and workforce plan
Official baselineSuperseded v1 input

Evidence register: official baselines and superseded v1 inputs.

Official statistics establish scale. The earlier v1 illustrative inputs ($412b base, 8% reduction and related placeholders) are no longer the party's scenario. They remain listed so readers can see what changed; the current scenario is the S38 11-system gross model.

Official baseline

Public-sector employment and wages

2.597m jobs; $249.5b wages; 2.211m state/local jobs; $208.7b state/local wages

Source / method: ABS, Public Sector Employment and Earnings, 2024–25

Date: Reference period: June 2025 / 2024–25; released 6 November 2025

Limitation: Headcount and cash wages are scale measures, not full-time-equivalent staffing, total employment cost, or a measure of duplicated roles.

Open official source
Superseded v1 input

Major-service cost base

$412b default

Source / method: Model allocation to be reconciled against ABS Government Finance Statistics, AIHW health and welfare spending, and the Productivity Commission Report on Government Services

Date: Model default prepared June 2025; source series should be refreshed to a common financial year

Limitation: Not an official aggregate. It spans different accounting boundaries and must exclude transfers, capital and internal transactions before use.

Open official source
Superseded v1 input

Duplication reduction

8% default; 4% low; 12% high

Source / method: Sensitivity range applied only to the modelled addressable base; no official benchmark is asserted

Date: Scenario assumption: June 2025

Limitation: Must be replaced by bottom-up agency process maps, protected frontline baselines, implementation timing and confidence intervals.

Superseded v1 input

Machinery-of-government dividend

$4b default

Source / method: Separate placeholder for corporate, governance, property, ICT and procurement consolidation after overlap removal

Date: Scenario assumption: June 2025

Limitation: Cannot be added to agency savings until contracts, stranded costs, asset disposals and duplicated categories are reconciled.

Superseded v1 input

Transition cost

$18b default

Source / method: Bottom-up cost envelope required for workforce, systems migration, property exits, legal change, communications and contingency

Date: Scenario assumption: June 2025

Limitation: No optimism-bias uplift, financing cost, schedule risk or jurisdiction-by-jurisdiction implementation plan is yet included.

Official anchor + rounded scenario

Household count

11m default

Source / method: ABS, Household and Family Projections, Australia, 2021 to 2046

Date: Released 4 July 2024; model uses a rounded near-term figure

Limitation: The per-household result is an arithmetic scale illustration, not a forecast of cash received by each household.

Open official source
Annual evidence control

Official baselines are reviewed, not silently replaced.

Last reviewed 8 September 2026; next review due 30 September 2027. A changed source value requires a model-version and reference-date update. Definition changes are reported as not comparable until a documented reconciliation is available, and earlier limitations remain visible.

Australian Bureau of Statistics

Check Public Sector Employment and Earnings and Government Finance Statistics for revised observations, definitions, coverage and the latest financial year.

Productivity Commission

Check the latest Report on Government Services tables, errata, service definitions and jurisdictional comparability notes.

Infrastructure Australia

Check appraisal guidance, assessment parameters and infrastructure market or pipeline releases used by any wider-benefit assumption.

Commonwealth, state and territory agencies

Check budget papers, annual reports, workforce releases and finance-department updates for all nine jurisdictions, recording the release and table used.

Comparability rule: headcount is not FTE; cash wages are not total employment cost; budget expenses, GFS transactions and service-specific expenditure are not interchangeable. Series with different coverage, accounting bases or definitions must not be combined without a published bridge.

From scenario to verified net

Seven steps before any benefit is booked.

  1. Step 1

    Reconcile the baseline

    Establish expenditure by function, jurisdiction and accounting year. Reconcile Commonwealth–state transfers and remove duplicated accounting entries.

  2. Step 2

    Separate removable and transferred costs

    Identify genuinely cashable costs rather than costs shifted to a national authority. Include regional staffing and new regulatory responsibilities.

  3. Step 3

    Cost every year of transition

    Estimate capital and operating expenditure including parallel running, contracts, data migration, pensions, legal work and cybersecurity.

  4. Step 4

    Evaluate service and equity outcomes

    Use verified before-and-after measures, independent counterfactuals where practical, and distributional and regional equity assessments.

  5. Step 5

    Calculate net fiscal impact

    Realised cashable savings minus incremental recurring costs minus transition costs. Report economic and social benefits separately.

  6. Step 6

    Test long-term uncertainty

    Publish justified discount rates and sensitivities for costs, savings, delays and service performance.

  7. Step 7

    Audit before booking benefits

    Require independent audit and parliamentary reporting before forecast savings are booked or reinvested.

What counts as a benefit

  • Audited cashable savings, net of recurring and transition costs
  • Service outcomes measured against published baselines
  • Regional equity and accessibility effects, reported separately
  • Never: purchaser bill changes or program costs blended into efficiency totals